Softball Batting Helmets

Choosing the right size helmet is key for safety. Here’s how to determine your size:

• Measure your dead circumference: Wrap a soft tape measure around the largest part of your head—starting from 1-2 fingers above your eyebrow and going around the back. Measure three times and choose the largest number.
• Sizing options: Helmet sizes are often listed as Youth, Adolescent, and Adult, or XS, S, M, L, XL. Be sure to check the manufacturer’s specific sizing chart. Like a bat or glove, a well-chosen helmet can “level up” your game.
• Hair: Consider how you wear your hair—ponytail, braid, bun?
• Accessories: Do you wear glasses, sunglasses, a headband, or a visor?

Ensure the helmet fits snugly on your head, sitting about 1 inch above your brow line, and there is no movement during the “Shake Test.” If there’s movement, the helmet is too big. Always opt for a snug fit, as padding will soften over time.

Even with the right helmet size, you may need to adjust the padding for a better fit. Some manufacturers sell separate padding kits to customize your fit and address gaps. Be sure not to remove any padding, as that could make your helmet illegal for competition. Remember, sometimes “more padding” isn’t always better—it's best to choose a slightly smaller size for maximum protection.

Helmet requirements vary by league, but there are general guidelines:

• Helmets must be worn at all times in live ball areas, including at bat, running the bases, and in the on-deck circle.
• The helmet must cover both ears and include a face guard.
• At the collegiate level, athletes can choose whether to wear a face guard, but leagues often require helmets with anti-glare material to ensure fielders maintain visibility.

For many female athletes, fitting their hair into their helmet is a top concern. A standard helmet may not accommodate a ponytail or bun. Some helmet brands, like Schutt, offer a “ponytail port” designed specifically for this purpose. However, it’s important to balance hair accommodations with the overall safety and fit of the helmet. Always ensure safety isn't compromised for convenience.

While bats and gloves come with various certifications, helmets only need one: NOCSAE certification. The NOCSAE (National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment) ensures that helmets have been tested to reduce injury risks, though it does not guarantee protection against all head injuries. Always check for the NOCSAE stamp before purchasing your helmet—this is the mark of approved safety standards.

Buying used gear is a sustainable way to score high-quality items at a fraction of the cost. Not only can you find great deals, but you might also stumble upon rare or discontinued gear that’s no longer available in stores. When buying a used batting helmet, here's what to look for:

✔️ Look for any visible cracks, dents, or deep scratches. 
✔️ Interior padding should be intact, not worn down or compressed. 
✔️ Ensure the chin strap is intact, functional, and not frayed. 
✔️ Inspect the outer shell for signs of wear, such as fading, scuffs, or peeling paint.
✔️ If the helmet includes a face guard or cage, check for bends, cracks, or misalignments. 
✔️ Certification sticker (like NOCSAE) that guarantees safety standards, even if used. 
✔️ Check for any signs of mold, mildew, or heavy dirt that might indicate neglect.

🏆 The best part of shopping used on SidelineSwap? We offer Buyer Protection and will issue you a full refund if your item is never shipped, arrives damaged, or is not as described. We also provide No-Questions-Asked returns with Seel. Learn more here.