Baseball glove buying guide

Every ball player knows the feeling. The final frost of Winter has come and gone, the days are getting longer, the leaves on the trees are back -- and so is baseball. You’re pumped to get back on the field with your buddies, but first, you have to prepare. Seasoned vets will tell you that gearing up for baseball season takes both physical and mental preparation.

But you’re not the only one who needs to get in shape for baseball season. Your glove needs to get in shape, too! It's crucial that you properly break in and take care of your glove before you jump into a new season. Maybe your glove has been sitting in the garage collecting dust all Winter. If that’s the case, we’ve got tips here to help you get your glove prepped and cleaned so that it’s ready to go. If you’re in the market for a brand new glove, we’ve also got you covered -- read on to learn about how to properly size a baseball glove, and to learn about what brand and model of baseball glove is best for your position.

How to size a baseball glove

When it comes to glove sizing, you definitely want to make sure you’re getting the proper fit for your hand size. Here are a few tips for how to measure a baseball glove.

Glove sizes are listed in inches. Most gloves will have their size etched into the leather, usually on the thumb or the pinky finger of the glove. If you have a glove in your possession and you’re not sure what size it is, you can always measure its length. Using a flexible tape measure, measure from the tip of a glove’s index finger to the bottom of the glove’s heel. The tape measure should be touching the glove at all times. Be sure to consult the size chart of the glove manufacturer you’re interested in purchasing a glove from. Most glove brands will run very similar sizes, but it’s always better to be safe than sorry. This chart provides a rough idea of how different glove sizes will generally fit by age group and position:


Gloves by position

The most obvious thing you need to know before you purchase a baseball glove is which arm you throw with. A “right hand throw” glove (RHT) is worn on your left hand; conversely, a “left hand throw” glove (LHT) is worn on your right hand. Different positions require different types of gloves as well. Let’s walk through each glove by position.

Catcher’s mitt

It’s important to note that catcher’s mitts are measured differently than infield, outfield and pitchers’ gloves. To size a catcher’s mitt, you want to measure the circumference of the glove, rather than its vertical measurement. Another key difference between catcher’s mitts and fielding gloves are the way the fingers are constructed. For fielding gloves, the fingers are separately cut. This is not the case with catcher’s mitts. All of your fingers are grouped together, which helps catchers catch fast balls repeatedly without pain, and without their hands getting tired. Catcher’s gloves also tend to be much stiffer than fielding gloves, so they take a longer time to break in.

Infield gloves

Infield gloves tend to be smaller in size compared to gloves for other positions. Infield glove pockets tend to be shallower and more open, too. The open pocket design allows players to transfer the ball quickly from their glove, which is good because making quick plays is key for infielders.

First base glove

First base gloves most closely resemble catcher’s mitts. They don’t have as much padding as catcher’s mitts, however, and they’re slightly longer. The longer glove design helps first basemen reach further and make diving catches more easily. First base gloves tend to have fairly deep pockets and usually have the same amount of catching area as catcher’s mitts do, but they’re not as rigid as catcher’s mitts. The flexible design of first base gloves makes them more efficient at scooping up ground balls.

Pitcher’s gloves

Comfort is key when it comes to pitcher’s gloves. They don’t tend to have a ton of padding, and they’re usually a lot larger than your typical infield glove. The larger surface area allows pitchers to disguise their hand placement around the ball, which helps them disguise their next pitch. All in all, you want your pitcher’s glove to be as comfortable and lightweight as possible.

Outfield gloves

You’ve seen the highlights: a center fielder, tracking a pop fly with his hand outstretched, waiting for the right moment to dive and make a SportsCenter Top 10-worthy play. Outfield gloves are usually longer and larger in size to help players make these big diving catches. They also tend to have deeper pockets for the same reason.

Baseball glove web types

Webbing is unique to every baseball glove, and it’s important to figure out which style of webbing you prefer. Outside of personal preference, your position on the field will dictate what webbing might work best for you. Certain webs are best for certain positions. Let’s walk through the main types of glove webs:

1.) I-web

I web baseball glove

An I-web is a pretty open style of glove webbing, and it’s a preferred choice among many infielders (second basemen and shortstops). The openness of an I-web allows any dirt you scoop up while fielding a ball to fall quickly out of your glove.

2.) H-web

H web baseball glove

H-webs -- or dual post webs -- are usually best for outfielders and third basemen. This style of webbing allows outfielders to see through their gloves when they’re looking up and tracking pop ups. H-webs provide a sturdy yet flexible glove experience.

3.) Closed/basket web

Basket web

Closed webs, or basket webs, are popular among pitchers and catchers. The completely closed web design is great for concealing the ball, which is obviously a priority for pitchers. Basket webs are also super flexible compared to other styles of webbing, making them easy to close.

4.) Two-piece closed web

Two piece closed web

The two-piece closed web has similar advantages to a basket web. It’s an ideal webbing for pitchers, because it completely conceals the ball.

5.) Trapeze web

Trapeze web

One of the most popular guys in the league to utilize a trapeze web is Mike Trout. Trapeze webs are pretty much only used by outfielders. They allow for a deep pocket, and they shield your eyes from the sun when you’re tracking a ball.

6.) Modified Trapeze Web

Modified trapeze web

Modified trapeze webs are close cousins of standard trapeze webs. The main difference is the addition of a strip of leather across the top of the web. This adds stability to the glove. The modified trapeze web is a bit more versatile, so it can be used by outfielders, infielders or pitchers.

How to break in a baseball glove

The hot water and mallet technique

As made popular by Wilson’s “Glove Guru,” Shigeaki Aso, this is a tried and true method to break in a new glove. Before you get started, you’ll need:

  • A bucket of hot water (Note: the water temp should be around 150-160 degrees; don’t use boiling water)
  • Plastic cup
  • Wooden mallet
  • Soft/cushioned surface

To start, fill your bucket with hot water. Using your plastic cup, gently pour water over the entire surface of your glove until it’s covered. Next, use your mallet (or your fist if you don’t have a mallet) to pound in the leather. Be sure to hit all areas of the glove. Next, put your glove on and use your mallet, a baseball or your other hand to pound in a pocket. Continue this process until you feel like you’ve achieved the pocket shape you desire.

How to use shaving cream to break in a glove

If you’re an old fan of ARod’s, you’ll be interested to learn about his (rather odd) technique for breaking in a glove. His secret? Shaving cream. Before we explain, it should be noted that he spent an entire year prepping his glove for the following season. So, if you’re on a time crunch, this method may not be the best idea for you. Before you get started, you’ll need:

  • Shaving cream
  • A buddy to play catch with
  • A freezer

ARod swore by the ability of shaving cream to break down leather. He would spend an entire year leading up to a season applying shaving cream regularly to his future glove. In addition to this shaving cream ritual, he would also routinely play long games of catch with a teammate to mold the glove’s pocket.

Once the season arrived and it was finally time to use his glove, ARod would put his glove in the freezer before every game. He’d take it out about 30 minutes before the start of a game. Why? He noticed that the summer heat often took a toll on glove leather. The humidity would cause a glove to become waterlogged, soft and heavy. His solution: the freezer. The cold climate would harden his glove and help restore its proper shape.

Using oil to break in and soften a glove

Bryce Harper is known for using oil to break in his glove. Here’s what you’ll need to get started:

  • Two buckets of water
  • Three baseballs
  • A sledgehammer (or baseball mallet)
  • String
  • Glove oil

First, fill one of your buckets with water. Next, pack the glove’s pocket with three baseballs and tie it closed with a long piece of string. Once the glove is stuffed, submerge it in your bucket for 24 hours. After a day of soaking, remove the glove from the water and untie the string wrapped around it. Remove the baseballs, and get your sledgehammer ready. We’d advise you do this in your backyard or in the garage. Place your wet glove on a flat surface, and pound it with your sledgehammer to work in the leather.

After you’ve done this, re-stuff your glove with the baseballs and tie it up once again. Be sure to use a fresh piece of string. Submerge your glove for 24 hours once again. After a second full day of soaking, remove your glove from the water, untie it and remove the baseballs. Allow your glove to fully dry. Once dry, it should be ready to go!

Harper suggests you use saddle oil on your glove frequently throughout the season. The routine application of oil will help keep your glove soft and help prevent it from cracking.

How to clean your baseball glove

Now that the season’s underway, your glove isn’t going to stay shiny and new. It will get dirty and scratched up as the season goes on, and it’s important that your take proper care to clean it regularly. Cleaning your glove should be an essential part of your routine each week during the season. The better you take care of your glove, the longer it will last. For proper glove cleaning, you will need a few tools in your arsenal:

  1. A brush
  2. A rag
  3. Leather cleaner
  4. Glove conditioner

Use your brush to regularly rub surface dirt off of your glove. You want to get rid of dirt as quickly as possible. The longer it stays on your glove, the more likely it is to harden into the leather. If it hardens, it will be harder to remove.

Once you’ve cleaned off surface dirt, use your leather cleaner and a rag to remove the more stubborn dirt from your glove. Remember not to use too much leather cleaner.

Next, it’s time for glove conditioner. The same rules apply here: be careful not to use too much conditioner, or you’ll risk having it build up within the glove’s leather. Be sure to wipe down all areas of your glove for the best results; that includes in between the fingers, and on the palm of the glove as well.

Most popular baseball glove brands

Even if you’re new to the sport, it’s a safe bet that you’ve heard of the following baseball glove manufacturers: Rawlings, Wilson, Easton, Marucci and Mizuno. These are probably the top five glove brands you can buy from. Of these five, Rawlings and Wilson are definitely the most popular, particularly at the MLB level. You can’t really go wrong in terms of deciding which brand is “best” for you. We suggest trying out a few different gloves across all brands, and then deciding where your allegiance lies. To get you started, here are few of the top glove lines and models from each brand:

Rawlings Gloves

Heart of the Hide

One of the most popular glove lines from Rawlings, HOH gloves come in a variety of sizes and specific models, including game-day glove models of some of the MLB’s biggest names, including Bryce Harper and Corey Seager. Each HOH glove is constructed with steerhide leather.

Pro Preferred

Rawlings’ Pro Preferred gloves are another popular choice among professional and elite level ballplayers. Pro Preferred gloves are crafted with supple kip leather.

Gold Glove

The Gold Glove series is championed for being redefined and achieving the ultimate standard in perfection.

Wilson Gloves


The Wilson A2000 comes in a variety of sizes, colors and specific models, and it’s easily one of the most popular gloves in all of baseball. People sometimes confuse the A2000 and the A2K, but they’re in fact very different gloves. The A2000 is older and less expensive than the A2K. It’s used by MLB stars including Robinson Cano, Carlos Correa and Clayton Kershaw.


The A2K is used by professional players such as Mookie Betts and Brandon Phillips. The A2K tends to be more expensive than the A2000 for numerous reasons. Namely, glove technicians spend three times as long working in the leather on A2K gloves than they do on A2000’s. This explains why the A2K has the reputation for being a softer glove than the A2000. The softer leather makes the A2K overall easier to break in.

Marucci Gloves

Founders Series

Invented in 2013, the Founders Series glove line utilizes premium Japanese kip leather.

HTG Series

The “Honor the Game” (HTG) Series from Marucci was designed with input from professional baseball players who wanted a glove that was more durable and game-ready than other options. HTG gloves use Premium A-Grade USA Steerhide.

Mizuno Gloves

We recommend checking out the following glove lines from Mizuno.

  1. Mizuno Pro Limited Edition gloves

  2. Mizuno MVP Prime gloves

Author image

About SidelineSwap Team

  • Boston, MA